Picture this. You have a large breed, deep-chested dog. You've heard all the warnings, taken all the advice and you are on high alert for signs of bloat, which if left untreated can be fatal. You open Instagram and scroll. In your feed is an ad for a slow feeder bowl. It's hard plastic, with fronds at the bottom to make the food harder to access. The voiceover on the ad recalls the day they say they almost lost their dog to bloat, and urges you not to make the same mistake they did. They tell you the unique design of their slow feeder bowl will prevent heartbreak. You feel the pull of fear, and you tap to add the item to your cart.
You're listening to a pet podcast. A manufacturer of a well-known slow feeder mat is today's guest, and on the episode they highlight the risks of competing products made of silicone, saying they can cause blockages if ingested, which can be really serious. You don't want your dog to eat something harmful - you can't afford the vet bills! You go into your kitchen and throw your dog's silicone lick bowls in the bin. You'll only buy products from this brand going forward.
It's been a long day. You're lying in bed, having a scroll on TikTok shop before going to sleep. Amidst the ads for cheap skincare, jumbo bags of rabbit ears and matching loungeware, you stumble across an ad for a "rubber" bone. You can unscrew the end to hide something scented inside, and you can even record your voice for your dog to hear, giving them comfort when you are out of the house. The toy even has a rechargeable battery, how handy! Brilliant, you think - the ad even says it prevents separation anxiety. You look over at your "velcro" dog, who follows you around the house from room to room and panics when you leave. Maybe this will help? You add to cart.
You're catching up with your friends posts on Facebook. An ad appears on your feed featuring some spaniels and a viral enrichment toy, where they talk about how long it took for their "high energy" breed to finish it. You look down at your own "high-energy" dog, and notice that he's chewed the skirting boards without you noticing. Again. You sigh as you tap the ad to buy the product. If he's busy working to get food out of an enrichment toy, then he can't wreck the house at the same time, can he?
Do any of these scenarios feel familiar? This is a very common marketing tactic!
Fear-based marketing
Fear-based marketing is a marketing technique which uses our fears and anxieties to motivate us to take an action - buy a product, sign up for a service, or otherwise change our behaviour.
Also known as "fear appeals", this technique appeals to our emotions in expectation that we will feel compelled to do something in response. The pattern here is -
- Identify an existing issue or threat of your target audience
- tell your target audience of the consequences of ignoring the threat
- offer a solution to the threat
- make it seem easy / logical to go with the solution presented
- profit!
The concern from the target audience being exploited (you, the consumer!) is often legitimate, but this type of marketing risks blurring into fear-mongering, where the threat or consequences of inaction are exaggerated or fabricated altogether. I am seeing more and more of this type of marketing, often paired with an absolutely terrible product that doesn't actually solve the fear being preyed on!
Whose problem is it anyway? The dog's - or the human's?
Often, so many of these products that are marketed in this way are designed to resolve human feelings of discomfort or irritation about their life with their dog, or prevent an undesired behaviour or outcome from the human perspective. Rarely are they designed with the dog in mind!
Keep them busy when you're out of the house with this plastic treat receptacle. Feed them from this bowl to reduce your anxiety about bloat. Chewing your furniture? Give them this nylon bone to chew instead. Dog not giving you a moment's peace at home? Here's a stuffable rubber toy you can freeze, it'll take them ages to get the food out and you can doom-scroll on the sofa in peace.
The human intentions here are good in many cases - you have a genuine concern, and you want to address it. You care about your dog and your relationship! This marketing messaging gives you the feeling of being proactive, taking action, which feels good and like you will make progress - but is it the right action?
Not enough thought is given to the dog. Dogs are captive and depend on their caregivers for all their basic needs - the least we can do is consider their wants and needs when making decisions about managing behaviours.
Many of the behaviours these products have been designed to "solve" are totally normal, natural behaviours for dogs. Yes - chewing, shredding, digging, seeking connection - even if we find them inconvenient! When we seek to "solve" them by giving them something to do instead, are we truly meeting the dog's needs, or are we meeting our own need for an easier life?
The "why" behind behaviour
All behaviour is communication. When we start to ask why a particular "problematic" behaviour (read: problematic to the human caregiver! The behaviour is functional for the dog!) is occuring, we might find our response becomes very different!
A dog who is digging up your sofa might have different reasons for doing so. Do they have gut pain? Are they trying to get comfortable and build a nest? Giving them something to dig may not actually resolve the problem.
A dog who is in distress when left home alone is not going to feel better because they have been left something to do when you go out. They aren't bored - they are struggling to cope with being apart from their caregiver. An enrichment toy might momentarily occupy them, but they are still going to feel distressed - it won't change their underlying emotional state.
A dog who is chewing up everything within reach at home is likely not going to stop this behaviour because they've been given something else to chew. There are lots of reasons they could be resorting to destruction - separation distress, boredom / unmet needs, pain or discomfort, or something in their environment causing them distress, for example. When we figure that out, we can work on resolving the issues.
Well then, what's the point of enrichment?
The above doesn't mean enrichment toys don't have a place - my whole business would be a waste of time and energy otherwise! - but we do need to consider what our companion's behaviour is telling us, and provide safe and appropriate outlets. A high-energy working line dog is not going to be satisfied with a snuffle mat!
Enrichment is just one piece of the puzzle in our relationship with our dogs. Sleep, nutrition, physical exercise, health, genetics, social relationships and so much more play a part! However, if our dog's needs have been met in a way that is individualised to them, then we are more likely to have a calm, happy and fulfilled dog.
Need help figuring out how to safely provide your dog opportunities to be a dog and have their needs met? Drop me a message through the website or on socials and I'd be more than happy to provide advice on picking the right activities. I can also work 1:1 with you to build an enrichment plan from your home!